Alex Toth — The Curious Case Of The Book That Never Happened
Hot Wheels #5, December 1970

I’m not sure who owned the complete original art for Alex Toth’s stunning “The Case of the Curious Classic,” but it was recently broken up and auctioned off. I bid quite aggressively for what I think is one of the best pages in the story.
This was also one of those comics I bought as a kid, so I had to do it. (“Had to.” Quick, call a therapist.)
And what a story. If you’re a fan of Toth’s work, this is one of the great ones. Even if you’re not, it might make you one. Written, penciled, and inked by Toth, it’s built around an atypical eight-panel grid, without ever feeling repetitive.
Heavy blacks, striking silhouettes, and beautifully spare drawing give it a noir atmosphere. The shifting angles and perspectives keep everything moving.
All this in a comic intended to help sell toy cars to kids. Toth apparently ignored the memo about doing the bare minimum on licensed titles.
I hope the Lucas Museum grabbed a page. This is exactly the kind of work I’d love to see represented there.
I’ve told a shorter version of this publishing adventure here before. Apparently, I’m still not over it.
We had hi-res scans of the complete story at IDW going back to at least 2010, and were fortunate enough to include it in the terrific hardcover Alex Toth: Genius, Illustrated, by Dean Mullaney and Bruce Canwell, from our Library of American Comics line.
But of course, we wanted more: all six issues of DC’s Hot Wheels in one volume, plus an Artist’s Edition portfolio of this story, similar to projects we’d done with Bernie Wrightson and Neal Adams.
Those never made it to print. There’s usually a reason these things stall, and it’s often the same one: getting the right people to sign off.
In this case, those people worked at Mattel.
We’d meet with them at least once a year, usually at Licensing Show, and make our pitch: we’d pay a small advance, pay royalties, send them copies, and do all the work.
DC wasn’t going to object. Their position was essentially, “We don’t own Hot Wheels. Mattel does.”
So, back to Mattel.
Lots of nodding. Lots of big smiles. Lots of “That sounds great!” Sometimes even, “Maybe you guys could do some new material, too.”
Then crickets.
Mattel was busy trying to become an entertainment company, and the management teams kept changing. So the next year, we’d often get to explain the whole thing to a new group of people.
Who also thought it sounded great.
I get it. The money involved wasn’t enough to make us much of a priority. These books matter, but nobody’s retiring on the proceeds. Still, if only these people could get out of their own way…
I hope someone out there is still chasing this. I’d certainly want a copy of the book we never got to publish.
And while we’re on the subject of Alex Toth and DC: isn’t it time for a complete collection of his DC stories? If DC doesn’t want to do it themselves, surely someone else would.
Abrams? Fantagraphics? Anyone?
I’ve already heard “That sounds great.” I’d like to see that book, too.













































































































